The 47 per cent question: Will CGT reforms mean rewriting PE and executive equity deals?

For twenty-five years, private equity firm deals with incoming executives have benefitted from an enticing incentive: equity was taxed at roughly half the rate of the executive salary rate. From 1 July 2027, that will change.

While the Investment teams at Private Equity firms continue in lobbying for grandfathering, a bigger question we’re hearing from sponsors and the leaders we place into their portfolio companies is this: if equity loses its tax advantage, how do you attract and keep great operators?

What's changed

The 50 per cent CGT discount is being replaced, for gains from 1 July 2027, by cost base indexation and a 30 per cent minimum tax. For top-rate taxpayers, the effective rate on capital gains moves from around 23.5 per cent to between 30 and 47 per cent.

Carry and management equity are set to be impacted by this. Both typically have a low cost base, and post-2027 gains will sit close to the top marginal rate. For assets held across the line, gains are split at the 30 June 2027 market value, which will make that valuation one of the most important numbers in any PE-backed business.

What we’re seeing

In the current market, PE firms are 'running the ruler' over potential investments for longer before committing. The cut-off may also create pressure to exit early, with deals structured around timing rather than the business plan.  

What about recent appointments?

Leaders who joined PE-backed businesses in the last 6 to 18 months are likely wondering what the future holds. They signed packages modelled at 23.5 per cent, and most of their value will be created after the cut-off. Many might be looking at up to 30 percent less equity for the same value creation.

Time will tell whether sponsors will revisit terms, and hopefully, staying through the hold still makes sense for both parties. Proven PE operators are in demand, and this group will be watched closely.

What executives want, and what sponsors can do

Executives are asking for certainty on the 2027 valuation method, a bigger equity slice or stronger ratchets, more cash in the package, earlier liquidity, and transparent modelling.

Sponsors who get ahead of this will reset terms with existing teams early, resize equity pools, blend in cash-settled incentives and retention payments, lock in the valuation approach now, and look at the start-up carve-out where it applies. Above all, they’ll sell the opportunity, not the tax. The best operators have always joined PE for the challenge, the pace and the quality of the sponsor.

Where to now?

The policy may still shift. Industry is pushing for grandfathering, the Greens are resisting carve-outs, and the Coalition and One Nation have said they’d reverse it. But no sponsor should build a talent strategy on a potential election result. Those who adapt first will have the pick of the best operators.

At Allura, we’re having these conversations with sponsors and executives now. If you’re rethinking how to attract or retain leadership, or working out what your package is worth, we’re happy to talk it through.

 

General commentary only, not tax or legal advice. Anyone affected should seek qualified advice on their own circumstances.

Sources: Australian Financial Review; Gilbert + Tobin; Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer.